14 Comments
User's avatar
Heidi Mordhorst's avatar

Linda, I saw that you were also reviewing TILT this week and did not look until I'd finished and published mine! I love that they are quite different and complementary, and I really appreciate the way you connect Darrah's story to your own--proof that it will land well with lots of TILT's reading audience.

Margaret Simon's avatar

Your personal story hits home for me as I had a similar note-passing incident in 8th grade that made me totally question who I was. I appreciate how this story leads to a wonderful review of Tilt. Finding that spot of pain as a tween is difficult to capture. Jone has a deep empathy for kids at that age and it shows up in the work she does.

Mary Lee Hahn's avatar

Such a powerful story from your childhood to lead into your review! My heart breaks that you never got to apologize, but I appreciate that you now use that experience to inform your life (and writing) moving forward.

Rose Cappelli's avatar

Thanks so much for sharing this review, Linda. I haven't yet read Tilt, but now I want to get to it ASAP.

Carol J. Labuzzetta's avatar

What a wonderful tribute to Jone to have so many of us review her novel. Thank you for linking the story to yours. As Heidi said, it shows how well it will resonate with tween readers. Fifth grade can be a difficult time.

Denise Krebs's avatar

Linda, thank you for sharing your beautiful review of TILT. I have read it already, and I am delighted that it is speaking to so many people. I know Jone is proud and happy that this story is finally into the world. Thanks for sharing your vulnerability too.

Jama Rattigan's avatar

Thanks for your thoughtful review and for sharing your own fifth grade friendship experience. TILT is on my summer reading list and I'm looking forward to digging in soon!!

Buffy's avatar

What a tribute to Jone's story that it brought you back to your own 5th grade. Thanks for the thoughtful review.

Patricia J. Franz's avatar

I so enjoyed TILT. It is beautifully written -- both TILT and your review. Thank you, Linda!

Janice Scully's avatar

I love how you tied together your 5th grade experience with Jone’s story. I also wish some of my early friendships could have ended in kindness or continued after an apology. Nice review, Linda!

Michelle Kogan's avatar

Thanks for this in depth and personal-tied review of Jone's new book, you really bring it home. Ten truly is a challenging age and sets us up for many things to come, I'm looking forward to reading TILT!

Cathy Stenquist's avatar

Beautiful post LInda. I am sorry for your experience with Cee Cee. Hopefully she, in some way, sees you now and hears your heartfelt words. Those childhood experiences are so tough and do hang with you through the years. But as you said, you now use your writing powers for good:). The review is lovely, and I will check it out. You have a great way of letting us into the story but not giving away too much. Hope you are finding a lot of time to relax and read this summer.

Karen Edmisten's avatar

Thanks for this thorough and thoughtful review, Linda, and for sharing your story about a hard time in childhood. There are so many rough waters to navigate as we grow up. 😢❤️

Jone MacCulloch's avatar

Linda, thank you for your review of Tilt. I love how you connected this with your own fifth grade past. I am sorry you never got to apologize to CeeCee. I hope that Tilt will reach other readers. This review might be what encourages them.